My Recipe Box

How to Make Your Own Feta

From curds to whey and where they separate—a step-by-step guide to a classic Mediterranean cheese.

How to Make Feta
Get the recipe: Homemade Feta

by Bonnie Jean Gorder-Hinchey

fromFine Cooking
Issue 100

Nothing compares to the fresh taste of homemade cheese. And tangy, rich feta is one of the easiest to make at home. It’s also an excellent “summer” cheese, the perfect partner to all those ripe tomatoes and gorgeous cucumbers.

Traditionally made with sheep’s milk, feta is equally delicious when made from store-bought cow’s milk. What gives it the distinctive sharp taste and crumbly texture is a week or more spent soaking, or aging, in a brine. Once you get your first taste of homemade feta, you’ll agree it was worth the wait. For complete how-tos, watch our step-by-step video, and follow the Homemade Feta recipe.

Day 1: Make the cheese curd

To understand the science behind cheesemaking, it’s helpful to remember that it began as a way of preserving milk. You start by encouraging milk to curdle so that you can separate the solid portion (the curds) from the liquid (the whey). Rennet, a natural enzyme, is added to cause curdling. You also add live cultures, here in the form of yogurt—these “eat” the milk sugar (lactose) and produce an acid, which lowers the milk’s pH. That acidic environment, along with heat, helps the rennet curdle the milk.

Once the milk coagulates into curds, you cut into it to let the whey flow out. The remaining whey is drained off by hanging the curd in cheesecloth for 24 hours at room temperature. Once drained, the cheese will have reformed into a solid mass, ready to be cut into cubes and then sprinkled with salt to draw out any remaining whey.

  • Heat the milk and add the rennet and calcium chloride, which help the curds form, and lipase, which lends feta's distinctive flavor.
  • Remove the milk from the heat, cover, and let sit undisturbed until the curd is firm and has a clean “cleave,” 1 to 3 hours.
  • With a table knife, cut the curd all the way to the bottom of the pot in a 1/2 -inch crosshatch pattern.
  • Pour the curd into a cheesecloth-lined strainer and let the whey drain off the whey for 30 minutes. Reserve 1 quart of the whey to make a brine for aging the feta.
  • Gather the ends of the cheesecloth and tie them loosely at the top of the curd,  then tie them around a long spoon or several chopsticks.
  • Hang the bag inside the pot at room temperature, loosely covering the top with plastic wrap. After 24 hours, you should feel a firm, solid mass of curds.

 

Days 2-4: Salt the feta
Salt and turn the feta for three days in a row to draw off more of the whey.

Sterilize the equipment you’ll need for this day of work. Clean all counters with hot soapy water or an antibacterial wipe. Untie the cheesecloth and transfer the feta to a cutting board.

Cut the feta into 2- to 3-inch pieces.Sprinkle about 1/2 oz. salt over all sides of the cheese. Cover and let sit at room temperature overnight. Repeat on days 3 and 4, turning the feta daily and resalting with 1/2 oz. salt. Each day, pour off the whey as it collects in the bottom of the container. 

 

 

Day 5: Brine the feta
Dissolve 2 oz. kosher salt in the reserved whey. Pour this brine over the cheese, covering it completely. Cover and refrigerate for 1 to 4 weeks.

 After three days, the cheese is put into a brine and aged for one to four weeks in the refrigerator. Although the cheese is ready to eat after one week, longer aging results in firmer, saltier, and more flavorful feta. When you make your own, you control the flavor and intensity of the tang, so you can make a feta that’s your idea of “just right.”

Three easy ideas for serving feta



Top with extra-virgin olive oil and serve with olives and crusty bread (pictured).

Drizzle with honey and cracked black peppercorns; serve with crackers.

Dress with fresh herbs and lemon juice and bake at 375°F until golden on top; spread on crusty bread.

Photos: Scott Phillips

Page:
header

MEET THE CHEFS FROM SEASON ONE

Cookbooks, DVDs & More