Baking Soda and Baking Powder - FineCooking.com

My Recipe Box
Food Science
FOOD SCIENCE

Baking Soda and Baking Powder

Illustration by Olaf Hajek

Illustration by Olaf Hajek

By Brian Geiger, contributor

October 28th, 2009

from Fine Cooking # 102, pp. 36-37

In junior high science class, I learned that baking soda was an alkaline powder. (Yes, I paid attention in junior high science.) Because baking soda is alkaline, when it’s mixed with acid, it neutralizes some or all of that acid, and in the process gives off carbon dioxide gas. My teacher demonstrated this memorably with a model volcano that bubbled up and erupted when he added vinegar to red food coloring and baking soda.

When I got into the kitchen as an adult, I remembered that volcano, and so I understood how baking soda works—the carbon dioxide gas that’s given off enlarges bubbles that already exist in a batter or dough, which helps baked goods rise. But what about baking powder? Since it didn’t get covered in my science class, I had to do my own research (fun!).

What's the difference?

I’m sure I’m not the only cook who has wondered if baking powder and baking soda are interchangeable, and why some recipes call for one, the other, or both. The fact is, both are leaveners, meaning they help baked goods like cakes, biscuits, and pancakes rise. The difference is in how they’re activated.

Baking soda (sodium bicarbonate, or NaHCO3 for all you geeks in training) needs an acid to enable it to give off the gas that enlarges a batter’s bubbles. This acid could be lemon juice, buttermilk, yogurt, or vinegar (remember the volcano?). But more baking soda doesn’t necessarily equal more lift. You want to use only enough to react with the amount of acid in your batter. Too much soda and not enough acid to activate it all means that you’ll have unreacted soda left over, which will create a bitter or soapy flavor.

Baking powder, on the other hand, is a complete package: it contains baking soda and enough acid to cause a balanced reaction. To activate it, all you need to do is add a liquid (which, by definition, a batter has to contain anyway).

Types of baking powder

Being self-contained isn’t baking powder’s only trick. When you mix wet and dry ingredients, baking powder activates instantly, enlarging bubbles in the batter and making it rise. But if you don’t work quickly and get the batter into the oven in just a few minutes, those bubbles will rise right out of the batter and into the air. So with a careful application of science, manufacturers have made baking powder work according to your schedule by using acids that don’t dissolve in water until they reach a certain temperature. (This is useful with batters and doughs that need to chill before going in the oven.)

That’s why you’ll sometimes see baking powder with different labels. “Fast-acting” reacts at room temperature. In “slow-acting” baking powder, the acid doesn’t dissolve until it reaches a higher temperature, so it won’t start rising until it hits the oven. “Double-acting” plays it both ways—it does some reacting at room temperature and finishes up its reaction in the oven. Most of the baking powders you find in the supermarket are double-acting; the other types are used mainly by restaurants and commercial bakers. If you find a baking powder on the shelf and its label doesn’t specify a type (or your recipe calls for just baking powder) you can assume it’s the double-acting type.
Homemade baking powder

There are two reasons you might want to make your own baking powder:

1. You get to choose the ingredients that go into it (and can avoid acids that contain aluminum, which may result in a metallic taste).

2. It will be really fresh (because if the purchased kind is kept on the shelf too long, moisture from the air can cause the acid to mix with the baking soda, thereby neutralizing both).

It’s simple to do. Mix two parts cream of tartar with one part baking soda and one part cornstarch. Store in a cool, dry place for up to several months. How long it lasts depends on how air-tight it’s stored, how often you open it, and the humidity.

To test the freshness of your baking powder, either homemade or purchased, add 1 tsp. to 1 cup of hot water. The mixture should bubble. If it doesn’t, toss it.

Choose your leavener

Generally, if you have a recipe that includes an acid (such as molasses added for flavor), you’d choose baking soda, which is activated by that acid. If you have a recipe that has no acid (say, eggs, milk, flour, and sugar), you’ll want baking powder as your leavening agent, because it has the acid built in. Also, double-acting baking powder has that delayed secondary rise when heat is applied.

But it’s not always this cut and dried: Some recipes use both baking soda and powder. These recipes usually contain some acidic ingredient, such as fruit or yogurt, but the carbon dioxide created when the baking soda reacts with the acid isn’t enough to leaven the amount of batter in the recipe. That’s where baking powder steps in, to add the necessary extra lift. It’s all a matter of having the right balance in the recipe.

Beyond lift: more flavor and better browning

Another reason to use both baking soda and powder is that they affect flavor and browning in different ways. Take this classic recipe for buttermilk pancakes. In it, buttermilk is used partly for its flavor. If you used baking soda alone, it could neutralize all of the buttermilk’s acid, and you’d lose that tanginess. But by including baking powder, which brings its own acid, some of the tang is left behind, and there’s still enough leavening for light-as-air pancakes.

As for browning, too much acid will inhibit it—browning happens best in an alkaline environment. Baking soda not only reacts with the acid to create lift in the pancake recipe, it also creates an alkaline environment. And that means better browning. If you left out the baking soda and used only baking powder in the pancakes, they would rise, but wouldn’t brown as well. So a golden-brown and delicious pancake is one that has a more alkaline pH.

With this tiny amount of chemical knowledge, you now have far greater control over your muffins, pancakes, and quick breads. Whether you want tangier, taller, or browner, using the proper leaveners in the proper ways will give you the baked treat you’re looking for.

posted in: Blogs, food geek, baking, baking soda, baking powder, leaveners
Comments (11)

Dejian writes: Hi, thanks for the very informative writeup. I am wondering about how you would treat milk (normal milk). Milk contains lactic acid. So in recipes requiring milk, should I add soda for added lift? Also, in a recipe that uses just lemon zest (not the juice), does the zest add any acidity to the batter and hence requires a baking soda?

Thanks Posted: 1:22 am on April 24th

TheFoodGeek writes: lululovesu, you don't have to alter the amount of baking soda that you use, but you should alter the amount of baking powder. Because you aren't using the cornstarch, you should use 3/4tsp of baking powder whenever 1 tsp of baking powder is called for, but keep the baking soda the same. Posted: 4:35 am on December 30th

lululovesu writes: Hi, I could use some help with this baking soda/powder thing. We have started to eliminate corn from our diets, and therefore we make our own baking powder. From what I have read it is 1/2 t Cream of Tartar and 1/4 t of Baking Soda = 1 tsp of Baking Powder. My question comes from when a recipe has both BP and BS. Do I need to alter my amount of BS if I am using a substitution for the BP? Or will the amount of BS stay the same. Posted: 2:28 am on December 30th

Bowl_of_Plenty writes: Wow, I completely missed out on this discussion!

To son of brooklyn: if you're making your own baking powder and plan to use it right away, then you can skip the cornstarch. If you plan on storing it, then it's good to include cornstarch in your powder mix since, as you know, it keeps the ingredients dry.

Regarding aluminum-free double-acting baking powders, the most widely available is probably Argo (Walmart carries it); Bob's Red Mill and Ener-G also make aluminum-free double-acting baking powders, and these brands should be available in natural-foods stores. Rumford is labeled double acting, but...isn't really. I think you'll find this discussion here useful:
http://www.thefreshloaf.com/node/12997/baking-powder
Posted: 12:24 am on December 12th

TheFoodGeek writes: Hi, 1Steve,

chefrox is correct, the molasses in the brown sugar is the acidic ingredient in your recipe. If you use older eggs, they will become alkaline and may neutralize some of the acidity, which may reduce fluff or add that soapy taste into your cookies.

son of brooklyn, a better way to know which baking powders to use is to check the ingredients and consult the table in Shirley Corriher's indispensable BakeWise (though the source of the table was from somewhere else entirely, that was the easiest way for me to find it). http://books.google.com/books?id=b-iwjIb2RxwC&lpg=PP1&pg=PT59#v=onepage&q=&f=false That table gives the percentage of carbon dioxide released at various points of the mixing and baking cycle, and will give you a better understanding of how your particular baking powder will react.

For your homemade powder if you're using immediately, feel free to ditch the cornstarch. Just remember not to use as much of the cornstarch-free baking powder as you otherwise would. Think about how much baking soda is being used in the whole baked good, and use accordingly. Posted: 11:28 am on November 24th

son_of_brooklyn writes: "If it doesn't say, assume it's double acting" is wrong for at least one product in my pantry.
If making my own baking powder and using immediately, could I eliminate the cornstarch, which I think just keeps it dry, preventing clumping?
Has anyone seen/used new product: aluminum-free, double acting baking powder? Posted: 9:25 am on November 23rd

chefrox writes: I believe it is in the molasses in the brown sugar. I could be wrong tho... Posted: 5:13 pm on November 21st

chefrox writes: I believe it is in the molasses in the brown sugar. I could be wrong tho... Posted: 5:13 pm on November 21st

1Steve writes: Where is the acid in this recipe? I know for baking soada it's there someplace?

Peanut Buttter Crinkles

Ingredients
1 cup peanut butter
1/2 cup butter
1 cup brown sugar
1 cup sugar
2 eggs
2 cups flour
1 teaspoon baking soda

Directions:
1. Cream peanut butter and butter until soft.
2. Add sugar gradually, continue to cream until light and fluffy.
3. Add eggs.
4. Beat well.
5. Mix in flour, salt and baking soda.
6. Drop 2 inches apart on ungreased baking sheet.
7. These should be about 1 1/2 inches in size.
8. Press each cookie down with a fork.
9. Do this a second time at a right angle.
10. Bake 8 to 10 minutes.
11. Do not overbake.
Posted: 7:28 am on November 21st

BasementBaker writes: Speaking as a person who has forgotten to put baking soda into cookie dough, if you don't include a leavening agent, the cookies turn out rock hard. The agent helps the cookies to spread and creates air pockets in the gluten network of the cookie to make the texture lighter. The cookies don't necessarily stay risen, but the agent is necessary for texture. Posted: 1:00 pm on November 6th

Fancygirl writes: If baking soda is a leavening agent, why is it used in cookies, especially crisp ones? Posted: 5:02 pm on November 5th

You must be logged in to post comments. Log in.

Cookbooks, DVDs & More