My Recipe Box
Test Kitchen
TEST KITCHEN

What Are Your Favorite Comfort Foods?

Need a little comfort these days? Us too. Since the question "What did you make this weekend?" is increasingly answered by dishes qualifying as comfort food, we thought it was a good time to share some favorites and ask what soothing meals you've felt compelled to make—or eat—lately.

Lisa starts us off:

When it comes to comfort foods, the making is as important as the eating, at least for me. That’s why this weekend, I pulled out my Dutch oven and cooked up a batch of Braised Short Ribs, using the recipe maker. I riffed on the Tunisian-inspired variation, using red wine, star anise, cinnamon, fennel, carrots, leeks and mint. As it braised in the oven for close to 3 hours, my house was infused with savory, exotic scents. That was the first part of the comfort. The second came in the eating—meaty goodness, meltingly tender, and rich with flavor. Served atop couscous and with a fruity red wine, it was received with sighs and groans around the dinner table, reminding me that sharing that type of comfort is often the whole point of cooking.
—Lisa Waddle, managing editor

***
For me, carbs usually equal comfort. At the top of my list of comforting dishes is a huge plate of spaghetti with brown butter and fresh sage, topped with a veritable snowdrift of grated Parmigiano-Reggiano. It’s not good for you, but it’s savory and cheesy and filling, and nothing in the world smells better than sage leaves sizzling in hot butter. Coming in a close second for me is our recipe for Cheddar and Cauliflower Soup. My mom used to make my sister and me a very similar dish when it was cold and snowy outside.  I like to add a bit more cayenne than the recipe calls for (about 1/4 tsp.); the resulting soup warms you right down to your toes.
—Denise Mickelsen, associate editor

***
I agree with Lisa that the making is as important as the eating—at least when I’m trying to comfort myself. When I’m feeling anxious or stressed, I turn to recipes that require a lot of repetitive hands-on work. This weekend, I made Simple Chocolate Truffles. The methodical rolling of forty-some balls of ganache, then dipping each of them in melted chocolate, puts me in a sort of meditative trance, and I swear lowers my blood pressure. One more reason chocolate is healthy! 
—Sarah Breckenridge, Web producer

Tunisian Braised Short Ribs   Cheddar and Cauliflour Soup   Simple Chocolate Truffles

***
For me, anything served with buttery mashed potatoes qualifies as comfort food. Or, better yet, mashed potatoes and celery root.
—Enid Johnson, senior copy/production editor

Rustic Mashed Potatoes   Garlic Mashed Potatoes   Potato & Celery Root Purée

***
Nothing says comfy family time to me more that a plate of my mom’s picadillo (mom's is similar to FC's Beef Picadillo), with fluffy white rice and platanos maduros, or fried plantains. It brings back memories of being back at my parents’ house in Queens. You could smell the picadillo from anywhere in the house, which always made me feel safe because I knew my folks were around. Now that my parents live far away, whenever I miss them, I make some picadillo and it takes me right back to that little blue house in Queens.
—Juli Roberts, editorial assistant

***
This might sound trite, but chicken soup (with acini di pepe pasta) is my go-to comfort food. My mom always had a pot on whenever we were sick or feeling down. Once, while in Italy, I got pretty sick and all I wanted was some good chicken soup, but instead was offered a plate of white rice. Totally not the same.
—Melissa Pellegrino, assistant food editor

***
I'm with you, Melissa—but for me, it's matzo ball soup. Recently, I came home from a long day at work, and found a pot of it bubbling on my stove—my mom had come over to my house late that afternoon, whipped some up, and left it waiting for me. What a treat.
—Rebecca Freedman, senior editor

***
Appears our comfort foods point back to the women who cooked for us, which makes total sense. Comfort food to me means my Auntie Mary’s shepherd’s pie, her homemade oatmeal, her French breakfast puffs (which I’m proud to say look exactly like The Pioneer Woman’s). Forget eating ice cream out of the box; I want to be back in my aunt’s kitchen. There wasn’t a problem that couldn’t be solved in the time it took to peel ten potatoes or gather our ingredients (or so it seemed). And, for sure, there are no problems good ol' macaronni & cheese can't solve—or at least cause you to temporarily forget.
—Robyn Aitken, Web producer

Beef Picadillo   Matzo Ball Soup   Baked Macaroni & Cheese

If you've got a favorite comfort food that never lets you down, leave a comment and tell us about it.

posted in: Blogs, comfort food
Comments (4)

Lulucooks writes: When in need of some warmth and comfort up here in the frozen North I make a soup similar to the cauliflower and cheddar soup above, but mine has corn and a touch of good quality curry powder in it. My other favourite comfort food is Arroz con Pollo, all the lovely aromas of saffron, lemon, olives, combined with the warmth and simplicity of this dish make it a winner for winter weeknight meals. Posted: 10:17 am on January 27th

sidneyfield writes: my family's comfort food is mac &cheese made with a rich bechemel of chedder & american cheese with panko bread crumbs and a dusting of paprika. This is a tie with our meatloaft which includes seasonings, ketchup, cider vinegar & brown sugar glaze with mashed potatoes. Did I mention a roaring fire while I prepare the meal? Posted: 11:04 pm on January 23rd

TheNaptimeChef writes: I am with you on the carb idea - mac&cheese with pancetta is definitely one of my favorite comfort foods! Posted: 2:09 pm on January 23rd

Annevdw54 writes: I would have to say when I need to feel warm and cozy inside,there are two things that will satisfy me. A good Homemade meatloaf with mashed potatoes and gravy or French Onion soup with French crust bread. Posted: 7:33 pm on January 21st

You must be logged in to post comments. Log in.

Cookbooks, DVDs & More