My Recipe Box
Cook The Issue #97

Buttermilk Cake with Spiced Vanilla Icing

By KaityCron, member

February 12th, 2009

I am not a baker, but this cake was very simple.  I think I got it all put together and in the oven in less than 20 minutes.  It would have taken me just as long to make a cake out of a box.  I cooked it for an hour and tested the center with a toothpick.  It came out clean but when I cut into it (the next morning) it looked like it wasn't quite cooked all the way through.  It tasted great, but I think it was denser because of this.  I took the cake with me to work and everyone loved it! I think they were surprised to learn that butternut squash was an ingredient.  I liked that this cake wasn't too sweet.  The icing added just enough sweetness.  I made my icing a little too thin. I did end up with a lot pooled on the cake plate.  Regardless, it hardened and looked very nice.  Since, I'm not a baker, baking is always a great learning experience.  I will make this cake again, I'll just need to invest in a Bundt pan (I borrowed the one I used from a friend). 

Recipe Used: Buttermilk Cake with Spiced Vanilla Icing

posted in: Gallery
Comments (4)

jaclyne writes: Hi KaityCron, also, don't be tempted to get a silicone one....I don't find they brown as well. Williams sonoma has a beautiful one that I've been eyeing for a while! Posted: 11:30 pm on February 12th

KaityCron writes: Thanks Pielove. The Bundt pan does look pretty with all the groves, but you are correct--it's a pain to clean! Posted: 10:51 pm on February 12th

bvgc writes: This cake is delicious!!! WEasy to make, and a crowd pleaser.
I have made it 3 times already. Posted: 9:13 pm on February 12th

Pielove writes: Hey KaityCron, we have adjacent posts and the same bundt pan. When you buy one for yourself, don't get this one-- the little grooves are a pain in the butt to clean and the cakes don't all release as perfectly as this one did. Your cake looks great by the way!
pie Posted: 8:18 pm on February 12th

Log in or create a free account to post a comment.

Cookbooks, DVDs & More


Update, March 6, 2009: This contest has now ended and we're tallying the results. The winner will be posted shortly. Feel free to continue to post your photos, though they will no longer be counted towards your total.

Over the course of two months, we’re challenging you to cook as many of the recipes in the February/March issue (issue 97) as you can, upload photos of what you make, and tell us what you love, what you don’t love, and what else you want to know.  Taking the challenge is easy. The most prolific member for this issue’s challenge will win a cookware shopping spree from, and fifty runners up will receive a copy of Fine Cooking’s Make it Tonight special issue.

For the complete contest rules, click here.