by mainemom36,
11/20/2012This is a favorite every time I make it. Perfect combination of ingredients to make it an extra special treat.
by Shootay,
11/28/2011I made this for Thanksgiving. It was excellent. The filling set well and wasn't too sweet. I thought the chocolate and bourbon were a little strong the day the pie was made. I refrigerated the leftovers, then set out at room temp to take the chill off before serving again. This did not do much for the crust, but the filling flavors tasted more balanced. The bourbon flavor was subtle but present. The chocolate was distinct but not as overwhelming as it was the first day when it was melted. Vanilla ice cream is a must.
by humbledj,
11/25/2011This was awesome, the only bad part about it is I was anticipating so much eating a lot of it and while I was changing my sons diaper all my guests ate it except for a little small piece. We served it with Tillamook Vanilla Bean icecream and it was great. I did switch out the crust recipe and used Spiced Rum,too. I do not know if my aforementioned little slice of heaven did not have enough chocolate in it, but I would add a little more chopped chocolate to it next time.
by surgeon92,
11/25/2011I used a different recipe for the pie crust when making this pie, so I can't comment on the crust recipe.
I think the bourbon was too subtle and the chocolate was far too bold. The pie filling tasted quite good in the bites that didn't have any chocolate. In the bites with chocolate, it just tasted like a chocolate bar. If I made this again, I would probably leave out the chocolate or cut it down by half or a quarter. If I left any in, I would chop it up quite fine and put it underneath the pecans. (I used un-chopped chocolate chips). I think this would improve the presentation of the pie and hopefully it would make the chocolate much more subtle. But, like I said, I would also consider leaving out the chocolate altogether.
On the positive side, this was fun to make as it was a nice variation on the traditional pecan pie. I think results would be very good if the chocolate would be made more subtle or taken out.
by winstonk,
11/25/2011An excellent recipe with great results but I gave it four-stars because, for my taste, the bourbon-chocolate somewhat overpowered the pecans. I must be something of a pecan pie purist having eaten so many wonderful samples of my mother's work who was raised in the Savannah, GA area. I will be trying David Guas' Classic Southern Pecan Pie recipe to see how it stacks up to my mom's gold standard.