It is important to cook the mushrooms long enough to brown them...same with onions. Cooking time patience will result in more flavor. I use beef tenderloin (choice cut is fine) and be sure to add FRESH dill springs finely chopped at the end.
I love this recipe!!! I get the top round that is already tenderized and it makes a huge difference. I cook the onions before the mushrooms and that away the onions are cooked and not crunchy.
This recipe was okay but not great. I hadn't made stroganoff in years and my memory is that my old JOC recipe or whatever I used back in the 70's was much better than this. I did like it because it was fast and easy, but my two biggest complaints are that the top round wasn't tender enough and the onions were too crunchy. If I made this particular recipe again I would use a more expensive cut of beef and I would cook the onions first, and then add the mushrooms so that the onions could cook longer.
Cannot agree with other reviewers who found this bland. I used 1 lb of mushrooms and some pretty good steak, and the depth of flavor was impressive considering there were no herbs & spices beyond just salt & pepper. Pretty easy to put together - make a double recipe and freeze some for later.
This recipe has replaced my old family favorite.
We enjoyed this stroganoff thoroughly. It is comfort food at its best. I was a bit surprised that the recipe didn't have more punch considering the complexity of the classic update matched with it, but it was delicious. You can read my full review at: http://bit.ly/wqfHT9
Found it to be a good recipe. Yes you can "tweak" it as other suggested, but hubby & I were satisfied with trying it just the way it was written. Comfort food that didn't take a lot of time & effort.
Made this last night as an homage to my mom who used to serve Beef Stroganoff as a special dinner. This recipe is a very good foundation to use and play with for your individual taste. I added wine and mustard to the sauce, as well as some cremini mushrooms, which gave it some nice body, and next time I think I'll use some Herbs d'Provence in addition. For the meat I bought some Prime Top Sirloin which was perfect, tender and tasty. Can't think of anything better to look back on my childhood 60's.
I did not read the comments before making this recipe either, ours turned out delicious :) I used regular salt & used plain yogurt instead of sour cream. Did not curdle.
Interesting comments... you all should have gotten the 'bland' part just by reading the ingredients on this recipe. There are no spices added that usually are part of the Stroganoff (paprika, parsley, maybe some worcestershire sauce or a bit of demiglace, dijon mustard and tomato paste and salt...) there is one rule in my kitchen: when you are cooking, you must taste! If it tastes bland in the pan, how do you expect the flavour to develop on the plate? I'm not trying to sound condescending but cooking is not an exact science (unlike baking...) and there is always room for experimentation. DeborahMS was bang on!
Everything was perfect but a bit bland on taste. I will be working from here to give it some kick. I think some red wine to deglaze the pan before the broth would help along with some red pepper flakes.
Agree with DeborahMS. I hadn't read the review before I made it. While I was eating, I had the exact thought.
We thought this was good, very good even, but not great, when prepared as written. The following modest tweaks add flavor complexity and the elusive 5th star: Stir into the sauce along with the broth: 1 tbsp. tomato paste (I love the kinds in the squeeze tube!), 2 tsp. dijon mustard, 2 tbsp. dry sherry (didn't have brandy or I'd have used that), 1/2 tsp. dill weed, a pinch of thyme. Simmer while the noodles cook, then stir in the sour cream just before serving to help avoid curdling problems. You may need to add a few tablespoons more of broth or a bit of your noodle water if the sauce becomes overly thick while simmering.