by Onymous,
5/20/2013These were delicious. Definitely a project- I do this kind of thing because I love big cooking/baking projects but if you don't, it's not for you. I've made this three times and my technique improved every time, so i had less butter leakage and higher rise. A tasty treat.
by user-134800,
4/24/2013After making these, I would say that 1. I am proud that these came from my two hands. 2. I have had some better and many worse croissants than these. 3. It is worth the effort for the experience and accomplishment, but if I was hosting a brunch, probably wouldn't add this project to the stress of hosting.
Recipe notes:
1. I used active dry yeast rather than instant bc it is what I had, turned out fine (activating it in water of course)
2. I don't have a stand mixer, used a combination of hand blender and old fashioned wooden spoon and elbow grease- also turned out fine
3. During the second and third dough lamination, my butter broke into shards visibly in the dough when rolling it out (though the bf was thoroughly entertained by the 'my butter sharded' comment). Not sure if it made a difference in the final product, though next time I think I will let the dough rest in the fridge rather than the freezer.
Even with the adaptions and issues, I still managed to come out with 15 tasty croissants and 3 mini's from the scraps. Made mostly plain and a few chocolate. Used the 3 day guide though next time would opt for 2 days or the commenter's guide who assembled the croissants the night before and then baked them off in the AM
by user-134800,
4/24/2013OK some people may exaggerate. I think if you live in a metro area that has professional bakeries (with professional grade ovens), you can find a better croissant. However, after making these, I would say that 1. I am proud that these came from my two hands. 2. I have had some better and many worse croissants than these. 3. It is worth the effort for the experience and accomplishment, if you are hosting a brunch, probably don't need to add this project to the stress of hosting.
Recipe notes:
1. I used active dry yeast rather than instant bc it is what I had, turned out fine (activating it in water of course)
2. I don't have a stand mixer, used a combination of hand blender and old fashioned wooden spoon and elbow grease- also turned out fine
3. During the second and third dough lamination, my butter broke into shards visibly in the dough when rolling it out (though the bf was thoroughly entertained by the 'my butter sharded' comment). Not sure if it made a difference in the final product, though next time I think I will let the dough rest in the fridge rather than the freezer
Even with the adaptions and issues, I still managed to come out with 15 tasty croissants and 3 mini's from the scraps. Made mostly plain and a few chocolate. Used the 3 day guide though next time would opt for 2 days or the commenter's guide who assembled the croissants the night before and then baked them off in the AM
by alinasim,
4/2/2013I too used this recipe and instruction for my first attempt at croissant making, and these are the best I've had since being in Paris. My question to anyone who can answer is, can i use a pasta roller for the lamination process - i feel like it may be quicker. any thoughts?
by RenoirIII,
3/5/2013Done it. Liked it. A bit of classical patisserie... I tried it with some pearl sugar through it which made it exceptional.
by grammalovestobake,
11/19/2012I have always wanted to try making croissants so I tested my wings with this recipe. The instructions were detailed and easy to understand. The croissants were outstanding. I used Plugra as others suggested. My mom is from Europe and loves fine pastries. She said these were the best she had ever eaten. That is high praise from her. Will definitely make these again.
by Arietanna,
10/11/2012I love love LOVED this recipe! It's my first time making Croissants and it came out soooo good. I was naughty and I baked it in the night round 9pm just to taunt my neighbors lol! I had to give them some cause it smelled great, it was soft, buttery sweet. The only thing I did not do was after the 3rd fold was chill it over night, I chilled it for an hour then rolled it, cut it, brush it and bake it. Great recipe thank you.
by binkiebun,
10/5/2012The step by step guide and pictures are so wonderful and so helpful! I just made these and they turned out beautifully. This was my first time making croissants, too! I did not have the patience to wait three days to see how these would turn out so I ended up omitting the first night of proofing in the fridge. I only put the initial dough in the fridge for a little over an hour (after researching other croissant recipes) and proceeded to roll out the dough with the butter square the same day. I did leave the dough in the fridge overnight after I was done rolling and folding. I was afraid my impatience would ruin the croissants but they came out perfectly puffed and layered. Right before baking, I chilled the croissants in the fridge for about 10 minutes to firm up the butter. (I learned from the internet that this can help prevent butter from melting out of the croissants when baking). The 425 temperature was too hot for my oven and I had to turn it down to 415. Baked 10 mins, turned the pan, and baked for another 8 minutes. I left the third tray in over 8 minutes and they started to burn a bit really quickly. So definitely keep watch of the oven at the end.
by saba123,
9/27/2012heyy.. can someone plz help me.!! while i was rolling my dough with the peice of butter .. butter came out from evry side and its a mess now.. wht do i do with it??!! plz help :(
by PeaceLoveDessert,
6/9/2012Amazingly easy to make! I always thought croissants would be terribly difficult. I am pleased to say it was easy :)
I made 20 croissants from this recipe and had enough dough left over to make 15 small cinnamon (cinnamon/raw sugar/cocoa/almond) rolls. Perfection! Having the step by step guide removed any worries I had.
by bessieheath,
5/16/2012Made these for the first time for Mother's Day brunch, with great results. I made a change in the timing that made this more approachable for serving at a morning event. I proofed the dough overnight the first night as indicated, then did my butter block & turns early the next day. I allowed the dough to rest for the day in the fridge, then shaped the croissants before going to bed the second night of the process. I proofed them in the fridge overnight, allowed them to stand at room temp for an hour or so, then baked them off before guests arrived. I would have had to get up at 4AM to shape & proof them in the morning. I had excellent results, no butter leakage. I used Plugra.
Addendum - I made these again, this time using organic cultured butter. Some of my family thought the Plugra batch was slightly better, others liked the cultured butter results more. Both were equally attractive.
by carrie77,
2/26/2012Considering what an intimidating project this is I was pleased with the results. The whole time I was wondering "Is this really going to come out as flaky croissants?". I can firmly say yes. I want to give it another go because the first time through I was just trying to make sure I was following the directions without having a clear picture of what each step should look like. Now I have a better idea of what I should be aiming for with each step. Nevertheless, at the end I had flaky croissants! Next time I might make fewer croissants so each one would be a little bigger, but maybe that's just because I didn't make them expand enough when proofing? A lot of butter leaked out during baking. The rolling out of the dough was difficult! But worth it. Looking forward to setting aside another weekend to this project in the future. Also-I put ham and cheese in half and chocolate in half. Good but I'd probably try just plain ones next time too.
by ceilidhsmith,
1/22/2012I didn't realize what I hassle these would be to make, but they turned out deliciously! I originally just read the top portion of the recipe that said you had to refrigerate overnight, not realizing this was a 3-day process! I only set the dough in the fridge for one night, and the two day recipe turned out just fine. Give yourself lots of time to roll out the dough...it definitely got my muscles working! Absolutely scrumptious!
by maciera1579,
8/30/2011The croissants came out absolutely delicious! In general, it is fairly difficult to get fresh, delicious croissants in the U.S., even in NYC where I live. I just came back from Las Vegas where I had a mediocre one from Payard at Caesar's Palace and it was $4 + tax for a single croissant.
Nothing compares to the taste of croissants using real, European-style butters (European butters have higher fat content compared to other butters). Thank you so much for the recipe!
by murray27,
2/27/2011These are the best croissants I've made yet. Using European-style butter is key to great results. Nowhere in my house was 75-80 degrees, but at about 70 degrees for two hours the final proof went fine. Be sure to bake these thoroughly so you bake through all of the layers.
by sjmeff,
12/28/2010This is a great recipe. The croissants came out beautifully. I'm a big fan of Hamelman's book "Bread" and was eager to try these once I saw that he was the author of this article. I made half regular and half chocolate. They were a big hit.
It takes about 3 hours on the final day to roll out, shape, proof and bake them, so you have to wake up early to have them ready for breakfast (they're also better when they've cooled for 30 minutes or so), so plan accordingly.
by sandraab,
12/23/2010Stunning result! I've made croissants before but this is the ultimate recipe. Maybe the best I have ever tasted and I have travelled all over France! The problem with many recipes is that they are designed for a professional kitchen which is usually much warmer than the domestic one, consequently, instructions tend to veer toward making the butter package too cold. If, like mine in winter it is only about 16-18 c, the butter can sit for a while before becoming too soft.
by Mosszz,
7/26/2010I love this recipe ! Best one i've ever found. Thank you so much for posting this one, Huge appeciation !
by FranVickie,
9/11/2009Loved the flavor & texture, the european butter made a big difference from my previous recipe. However, mine were not perfect the first time. My previous recipe used warm water and the dough did rise between steps, but these didn't rise at all until baking (nor during proofing - perhaps it wasn't warm enough)? Also, I had a fair amount of butter leak out during baking. It seemed as if the butter was too cold to roll out and stayed in clumps, but the recipe even mentioned freezing the dough, so I'm unsure what the problem was. I will try again, but if there are things I missed - please let me know! (I'm an occaisional baker).
by Texasprincess,
7/18/2009Yea Bunnycucina,
How can you rate a recipe when you are too lazy or uncapable of making it? The whole idea here is for cooks to give feeback on the recipe that they have made. Not to say how hard it is or to suggest buying them instead of making them. You are missing the whole point!
by munchrat,
2/3/2009Great recipe!!! Great instructions, very easy to follow. My first attempt and they came out. Light and flaky, the outside shatters into crispy shards and the inside is soft and buttery. I used European style butter and it was well worth it! Made my second attempt this morning and the results were the same. This time I rolled Guittard's Bittersweet chocolate squares inside of them. They were divine when they came right out of the oven. I have made so far 7 batches of croissants from this recipe and the best batch was made with a block of Lactantia's "Cultured Butter" that we had picked up on our recent trip to Canada.
by BunnyCucina,
3/4/2009Maybe no-knead bread has made me lazy, but I'm impressed with anyone who would bother to make these at home. I guess if I lived somewhere that didn't have wonderful French bakeries to go to I'd consider this, but to me this type of baking is best left to the professionals. It's a fuss and a mess and I'd prefer to gladly just fork over my $2 to Pain Perdu for one of their wonderful butter croissants. (Key word, ONE. Having dozens of those things lying around your house is an invitation to overindulge!)
by SaveYourBuckscom,
3/2/2009Looks very simple. Looks like I will be doing Croissants tonight! I have a new gadget that is going to make my cooking a lot easier and I want to play with it. Here is the video if anyone is interested http://tinyurl.com/b4vq7j
THANKS FOR A GREAT RECIPE! Fine Cooking is awesome!
by msmpt,
2/15/2009Excellent recipe, good instruction... do not skimp on the quality of the butter, I used a store brand and could tell the difference right away.Still delicious and gorgeous to look at!
I've remade this recipe last week and have a recommendation. Proof in a colder temperature than posted in the recipe (60 degrees). Before baking off, place in refrigerator for 15 minutes. The results are spectacular and there is no butter leakage.
by eloeb,
2/5/2009If I could rate these more than five stars, I would. They were flaky, delicate and looked like croissants you'd see at a fine French bakery. It was worth the work. I used European butter and made an almond paste to put in some of them; fine chocolate in others. Sublime!
by HotKitchen,
2/1/2009Makes a glorious, authentic croissant! A bit painstaking, requiring patience (even with the 2 rather than 3 day version)- worth it when you bite into the exquisite results. Worth the effort, though I won't be doing it weekly :)
by Elonios,
1/20/2009I have always wanted to make homemade croissants and these were so worth it! My friend and I made chocolate and regular. The layers were beautiful, they were so flaky. When they sit overnight they get a bit hard so it's nice to reheat them. We ended up getting 18 out of the scraps of dough,