by pharmFoodie314, 11/8/2015
This is one excellent cookie, rated so by a really tough crowd. I confess to bumping up the ginger, both ground and crystallized, just for personal taste. The texture is perfect and it's an effortless recipe. I am new to fine Cooking and have come to trust their recipes as reliable.
by LArcher, 12/6/2014
These cookies are amazing! My husband's favorite cookie is ginger cookies and these are his new favorite. I have been making these cookies for years and have shared this recipe many times with friends. Had to rate it to share my enthusiasm for this cookie because it is a must bake every Christmas!
by user-3212569, 2/20/2014
Perfect texture. I wasn't sure if I was supposed to be creaming the butter and sugar in the first step. I did for about 3 minutes with my egg beater. These cookies really spread. With my size large cookie scoop from the pampered cheif I will need to remeber to just put 2 rows on the cookie sheet, to give these guys enough room. I used 1/2 whole wheat flour and 1/2 all purpose. It was slightly crisp on the outside a d chewy inside. The sugar to spice ratio is a bit sweet for me. I want the spice to shine through a bit more so I am going to try and cut back the first batch of sugar to 3/4 cup, instead of 1 cup but I will keep the 1/3 for rolling in as it didn't get all used up anyway. Lots of fun with my 6 year old son. He said it was 1000 stars good.
by user-368239, 12/22/2013
I love this recipe. It is always a hit among my friends and guests. Thanks!!!!
by mattsatt, 11/19/2013
Upon looking at the ingredient list, I thought (and I surmise many other people think this as well), "That is A LOT of ginger." I thought it might make these cookies too spicy. I decided to try them anyway, since the reviews were so favorable. I'm glad I did; these are delicious! Definitely the best ginger cookie I have tasted. Don't be afraid of the seemingly excessive amount of ginger. The recipe calls for just the right amount. I followed the advice of the previous reviewer who froze the crystalized ginger before chopping it, and that definitely helps. And I love the other previous reviewer's idea of dipping these in dark chocolate! One warning, though: if you like sweet cookies, these may not be for you. If you like "sweets" that aren't overly sweet, then these may be your new favorite cookies.
by fortkcook, 12/27/2012
A definite keeper for holidays or anytime. Crystallized ginger makes these extra special. (I used Ginger People brand, available at Whole Foods). I baked one batch for less time and got a softer cookie, and I let another batch get fairly brown, resulting in a crisp ginger snap. Both versions great, though I prefer the crispy. Using the small ice cream scoop as suggested made these cookies nice and uniform, perfect for gift giving.
by aynil75495, 10/1/2012
These are quick, easy, & delicious! I did use some light brown sugar with the granulated sugar. I didn't have any candied ginger on hand but they were still tasty and I imagine even better with the ginger. Next time I think I will partially dip them in dark chocolate for holiday gifts.
by Mebsey, 3/9/2012
I stuck to the recipe exactly the first time I made these and they were awesome! My father, a ginger connoisseur, said they were just like the ones you get at the store. I made them a second time with molasses AND maple syrup and they were even better!
by FreddieFlea, 12/31/2011
EXCELLENT! These are really good, not too sweet. Perfect texture and great instructions.
I use white whole wheat flour which was good. Also, freezing the ginger for a few minutes and keeping the knife clean & cold, and chopping in small batches makes the ginger easier to handle.
by Nora_K, 12/6/2011
These are simple to make and oh so delicious! Best ginger cookies ever! I love that they soft for a few days. I bake things for friends and family for Christmas and these are so getting included this year.
by ilovebaking2, 8/23/2011
These are the BEST ginger cookies ever!! I use a soft diced crystallized ginger from KA flour company in the place of the crystallized dry ginger and the results have always been exceptional. I would recommend this to everyone. Makes great cookie gifts at the Holidays.
by AuntieMame, 12/28/2009
Easy and delicious! The perfect dessert. Next time, I'm going to try dipping half of each cookie in semi-sweet chocolate as a new variation.
by Ftrujillo, 11/16/2008
Really easy to make and a big hit! I love that they are soft for a few days. Yum.
by Picco, 3/13/2008
Excellent cookies and easy to make. Not a huge fan of ginger? Omit the crystallized ginger and add 1 Tbsp of Cinnamon and 1/2 Tsp of Allspice for Spice Crackles. I have made this change a dozen times with great success!
by emcooks, 12/23/2007
These cookies are amazing. They are moist and chewy, with a delicious ginger and butter taste. I have made these many times, since they are so easy and fabulous. They always get raves!
by merlincat, 12/18/2007
These are fantastic. I made about six types of cookies for a party, and these were the surprise favorites - incredible gingery flavor, great texture. People loved them and gobbled them down.
by difrei, 10/21/2007
I absolutely love these cookies. I always make sure not too bake them too long so they stay nice and chewy.
by Sadiecat, 10/10/2007
These are fantastic! Chewy and intensely gingery. The crystallized ginger makes all the difference.