by JSBuck,
1/2/2012This wasn't the easiest cookie recipe but it was certainly worth it! I tend to prefer one-bowl, toss-it-all-in, type recipes with as few steps as possible but this was a lot of fun to make and they were a HUGE hit with family, neighbors, co-workers and especially the kids! I don't tend to ice my cookies but these were show-stoppers and so yummy. Not sure what the other reviewer did but the dough was perfect - not flaky at all. Highly recommend!
by prezlnielsen,
12/5/2010Family LOVED them and kept going back for more! Brought them into work, and my work loved them! The recipe ended up making 40+ cookies!
I accidently doubled the icing recipe - I also made it with dried eggwhites (which lacks a few of the ingredients of Meringue. Took awhile for the "inner" layer of the icing to toughen up.
I really don't know what the other reviewer did, but these cookies were not flaky. They came out very moist, and had quite the bite to them. I wasn't able to find a snowflake cookie cutter, so I instead did different xmas shapes, and iced them with different colours! They looked beautiful!
by rotangus,
12/13/2009Very disappointing. Experienced cookie baker followed method exactly. Only substitution we did was using 1/4 tsp Chinese 5 spice powder instead of ground cloves. Dough was way too flaky, dry and crumbly to roll out into cuttable shapes. However we salvaged the experience, turning it into a pat-into-pan crust for pumpkin pie, and that worked quite well. Flavor of dough was excellent though.