Carrot cake is my son's favorite cake and I make it every year for his birthday. Last year, I made a number of different carrot cakes for him to "test" and this one was clearly the winner. It even beat out Nick Malgieri/Martha Turner's carrot cake. Look no further, Greg Case's cake is so moist and is the best!
This is the BEST carrot cake I have ever made. I make it several times a year since it was published in FC. I have even made it as a wedding cake.
This is a great carrot cake! Everyone absolutely loved it! The frosting is barely sweetened. For me, it wasn't quite sweet enough. That is just my personal opinion though because all of the guests raved over it and loved it because it wasn't too sweet. The cake itself was delicious!!!
Can be a little challenging, especially for first time cake-makers, but the work is totally worth it. Very moist cake, nice texture and layered with flavors. The frosting is rich and creamy and not too sweet. My Step Mom LOVES carrot cake and this is her all-time favorite!
This cake is absolutely fantastic! I must confess I've never tried it with the walnut oil, just canola. But we enjoy this every Easter and just LOVE it.
I served this at my annual holday party, and everyone raved -- best carrot cake they'd ever had. The cake was moist with a fine crumb, and the icing was not overly sweet but satiny and a perfect foil for the cake.