I gave this a 1 because it is a SHAMELESS attempt to give the illusion of a healthier alternative. Also if you are going to do that DO NOT take out the original. SHAME on you!!
Scrumptious! I substituted 4 oz. of (cold) sesame tahini for half the butter. Maybe for this reason, the dough was quite pliable, and the cookies spread nicely in the oven. The tahini gave the cookies a slightly bitter taste, like that of halvah. Instead of chopping up chocolate, I used 8 oz. of Ghirardelli 60% Cacao Bittersweet Chocolate Chips. Lacking a stand mixer (and having arthritic wrists), I used a hand-held mixer, at medium speed, to cream the butter and sugar. (I think it took about 10 minutes.) All in all, though, this was an easy recipe and well worth the effort. The cookies were soft and chewy, as promised (though possibly sweeter then absolutely necessary).
Made by my daughter. Good but not the best chocolate chip cookies.
This cookie has just about everything one could want in a crisp chocolate chip cookie. Everything except enough chocolate chips, a shortcoming easily remedied by doubling the amount indicated in the original recipe. I used a 60% cocoa chip which provided great, dark chocolate flavor. I also added about a cup of chopped nuts - walnuts, almonds, pecans, whatever. They're great while still warm, but fantastic once cooled, as well. The group with which I shared them, lest I eat them all, raved. You will, too!
What a fabulous chocolate chip cookie! And a lot healthier than the normal cookie. I did make some changes: I used King Arthur Flour - Unbleached WHITE Whole Wheat Flour -- it's not pure white, but it's lighter in color than regular whole wheat which in turn creates a lighter color cookie. I also added 3 tablespoons of Whole Ground Flaxseed Meal....it adds nutrients without any taste, at all. Great way to sneak some good stuff into your kids' tasty treats without them even knowing. After mixing, I refrigerated it for a couple of hours. Then cut the mix into 3 tablespoon sized blocks and rolled them into a ball. I otherwise followed the recipe exactly and I created 33 nice sized cookies.
I just made these cookies and they are spectacular! Using an excellent quality chocolate is very important. I'm in a tropical climate without A/C and I put the batter in the fridge between each batch, which helped to keep the cookies from spreading so much, as did using a silpat sheet (no parchment available). I also made them smaller, 1Tbsp each and cut baking time to 8 min. Next time I might try substituting a bit of applesauce for some of the butter to make them slightly healthier.
I too found that these cookies did not spread and they almost had a sawdust consistency. I probably would not make this recipe again.
Surprised at how tasty these cookies are! I used Anita's Organic Fine grind whole wheat flour. The fine ground flour gave it the same consistency of white flour. Delish!
I bought this cookbook and have made these cookies several times. I think these are some of the best chocolate chip cookies I've ever made. They have a nutty and almost caramel flavor with nice crispy edges. Be sure to use good quality chocolate, I used Scharffen Berger 70%.
I love these cookies. I disagree that they are indistinguishable from cookies made with white flour - they are different, but they are really good. They are not too sweet and the taste and texture are interesting - a bit crumbly. I have made them twice and will make them again. I've used Splenda and polyol-sweetened chocolate chips with good results.
These cookies are great! I love baking chocolate chip cookies and this recipe is just as good! You don't notice the whole wheat flour and the Bittersweet chocolate is perfect! Just the right amount of salt too!
I didn't like these at all. A big waste of expensive chocolate. The 3 TBL of cookie dough is way too much and they didn't spread at all - they were basically hockey pucks that I threw away with almost no flavor - a big disappointment.
I am always looking for good whole grain recipes. Regular chocolate chip cookies are too sugary. These are great. You wouldn't know they were whole wheat. I used a good Swiss dark chocolate and added dried raspberries as well. A great recipe as a base for lots of variations.