My Recipe Box

Perfect Thanksgiving Pies

Thanksgiving pie recipes

To some, Thanksgiving is just one big excuse to eat pie. Lots of pie. We understand that. Here, we’re sharing our best Thanksgiving pie recipes, from spiced-up pumpkin to classic apple to chocolaty pecan, all with tender, buttery crusts.


Sugar & Spice Pumpkin Pie

It’s the brandied ginger cream that takes this pumpkin pie over the edge. Reviewers rave about the recipe’s pumpkin-y flavor and light, creamy texture.

view recipe

Classic Apple Pie

A classic meal calls for a classic pie. The filling is a lovely blend of sweet Cortlands and tangy Granny Smiths, laced with just enough sugar and spice to make the apples’ flavors sing.

view recipe

Chocolate Espresso Pecan Pie

Chocolate lovers, this is the pecan pie for you, but be quick. People who’ve baked this pie for Thanksgiving claim it’s the first to disappear.

view recipe

Fresh Pear Pie with Dried Cherries & Brown Sugar Streusel

A hint of spice lets the delicate flavor of the pears shine through, while the dried cherries are a welcome alternative to traditional raisins.

view recipe

Coffee-Toffee Pecan Pie

With notes of butterscotch, espresso, and bourbon, this is a pecan pie like no other.

view recipe

Sweet Potato Pie

Because of its similar texture, sweet potato is a natural stand-in for pumpkin in this spin on the traditional Thanksgiving pie.

Visit the Guide to Thanksgiving Dinner for more pies and Thanksgiving desserts.

view recipe

Autumn Fruit Pie

With subtle Anjou pears and sweet-tart fresh cranberries, this is apple pie dressed up for the holidays.

view recipe

Classic Southern Pecan Pie

This is not one of those overly sugary, super-gooey pecan pies. Instead, this version strikes just the right balance—the filling is rich but not cloying, so the pecans take center stage, and the flaky, tender crust has enough salt in it to offset the sweetness of the filling.

view recipe

Caramel Velvet Apple Pie

Combining caramel and apple in a dessert is reminiscent of a childhood favorite, but there’s nothing childlike about this pie. The filling’s caramel flavor is sophisticated and elegant, and the baked apple texture is downright velvety. Put them together and you have a filling that’s a far cry from its stick-to-your-teeth candy-apple cousin.

view recipe

Classic Pumpkin Pie

This pie has it all—a flaky, buttery crust and a creamy, spiced pumpkin filling. You can make the crust and even bake the pie before the big day, so there’s absolutely no excuse for buying a pie for Thanksgiving.

view recipe

Ginger-Spice Cranberry-Apple Streusel Pie

Tart apples and cranberries are tempered with a nutty, sweet streusel and a hint of cardamom in this elegant Thanksgiving dessert.

view recipe

Skip this ad

Make it Tonight

Cookbooks, DVDs & More