Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Check Icon Print Icon Note Icon Heart Icon Filled Heart Icon Single Arrow Icon Double Arrow Icon Hamburger Icon TV Icon Close Icon Sorted Hamburger/Search Icon

Create Your Own Ice Cream Finalists

Save to Recipe Box
Add Private Note
Saved Add to List

    Add to List

Add Recipe Note

We’re thrilled with all the creative entries in the Create Your Own Ice Cream Contest. Narrowing it down to ten finalists was tough, and left us weak with cravings. Here are the ten that we felt best took David Lebovitz’s basic formula and turned it into delicious and creative treats. Vote on your favorite below!

Banana Bread Mac Nut Crunch   Coffee Gingerbread Chip Ice Cream
LadyBugThePug’s Banana Bread Mac Nut Crunch: Vanilla ice cream with banana bread chunks and macadamias   NuggetMonkey’s coffee-infused ice cream with chocolate chips, toasted almonds, and gingerbread chunks
Spicy White Chocolate Ice Cream   Jalapeno Lime Ice Cream
Guimauve’s Spicy White-Chocolate Ice Cream with crushed pink peppercorns folded in   KeeleyC’s icy-hot Jalapeno-Lime Ice Cream, flavored with chopped chiles plus lime zest and juice.
Malted Milk Ice Cream   Sweet Potato Ice Cream
Pesky One’s Malted Milk Ice Cream, topped with chocolate-covered peanuts   Brynnie’s Sweet Potato Ice Cream, here sandwiched between two bourbon sugar cookies
Straberry-Balsamic Ice Cream   Monkey Bite Ice Cream
Canadian Foodie’s Strawberry-Balsamic-Black Peppercorn Ice Cream, with a balsamic drizzle   KarenKitchen’s Monkey Bite Ice Cream: Banana-flavored custard, with chopped chocolate and peanut mix-ins.
NW Caffeine Buzz Ice Cream   Lemon-Ginger Ice Cream
Trav45’s NW Caffeine Buzz: Coffee-infused ice cream with roasted blackberries and chocolate-covered coffee beans   Texas Foodie’s Lemon and Ginger-Infused Ice Cream, here sandwiched between two different types of ginger cookies


Voting is open until 11:59 pm Eastern Time, July 29.

Finally, two honorable mentions: both LegalCat and NJacobsons have recently won gallery contests so we didn’t select them as finalists, but their inspired creations deserve a shout-out:

Pale Ale Ice Cream with Caramel-Stout Syrup   Triple Berry Ice Cream with Cocoa Nibs
LegalCat’s Pale Ale Ice Cream with Stout Syrup   NJacobson’s Triple-Berry Ice Cream with Cocoa Nibs


Leave a Comment


  • CarlaE | 07/23/2009


  • User avater
    sbreckenridge | 07/17/2009

    Voting is open until end of the day (midnight) July 29. I'll update the post to reflect that.

  • vics | 07/16/2009

    How long do we have to vote? I'd like to make all the ice creams and vote, but am going on vacation tomorrow.

  • User avater
    JuliRoberts | 07/14/2009

    Seriously....how can you choose from this Smörgåsbord of succulence!

    I'll take one of each please! :)

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published.


View All


Follow Fine Cooking on your favorite social networks

We hope you’ve enjoyed your free articles. To keep reading, subscribe today.

Get the print magazine, 25 years of back issues online, over 7,000 recipes, and more.