Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Check Icon Print Icon Note Icon Heart Icon Filled Heart Icon Single Arrow Icon Double Arrow Icon Hamburger Icon TV Icon Close Icon Sorted Hamburger/Search Icon

How to Make Homemade Tortillas and Tacos

Take a lesson from Mexican cooking guru Shelley Wiseman at The Farm Cooking School

August/September 2018 Issue
Save to Recipe Box
Add Private Note
Saved Add to List

    Add to List

Add Recipe Note

Certain foods just put you in a good mood. Tacos, for example. The simple combination of corn tortillas, savory fillings, and zingy salsa never fails to make my day. Whether it’s grilled veggies, rich carnitas, or spicy shrimp, my favorite way to eat them is taco style.

Of course, there can be no tacos without tortillas, so it’s important to start with the best, says Shelley Wiseman, one of the taco’s biggest fans and most inventive adapters (she even wrote a book on it, Just Tacos). “There are plenty of wonderful tortillas out there,” she says, “but not even the best of them can hold a candle to the ones you make from scratch.”

I visited Wiseman, partner in The Farm Cooking School, in Titusville, New Jersey (and former Fine Cooking and Gourmet magazine food editor), on a perfect summer morning to attend one of the school’s regular classes on Mexican cooking. I was delighted to discover how easy making tortillas can be.

At the start of class, dough for flour tortillas was already resting on the counter, having been mixed and kneaded an hour before. To one batch, Wiseman had added fresh cilantro, that quintessential herb of the Mexican kitchen. As students began mixing the masa harina, salt, and water for corn tortillas—unlike their flour counterparts, corn tortillas don’t require resting and rolling—they peppered Wiseman with questions. “There are no big secrets to making tortillas,” she explained. “Just don’t overwork the dough. You want it to feel like fresh Play-Doh.”

We took turns placing the masa dough just so in the press, and then cooking the tortillas on a comal, the traditional Mexican cast-iron disk used as a griddle. (“A regular griddle works just as well,” Wiseman said.) The first time we turned our tortillas on the griddle, some puffed up perfectly, and others were a bit too thin and delicate. Wiseman encouraged another try, and another, and gradually, we fell into a rhythm and created stacks of perfect ready-to-fill corn tortillas. We placed them in the oven to keep warm.

How to Make Corn Tortillas

Next, Wiseman taught the group how to roll flour tortillas into thin 6-inch rounds and cook them on the griddle just until pale brown spots appear on the underside.

Ian Knauer
Ian Knauer is Shelley Wiseman’s partner in the Farm Cooking School.

While the tortillas cooked, Wiseman’s partner in the school, Ian Knauer, a former Gourmet colleague, was outdoors playing with fire: grilling chicken and vegetables for taco fillings and also baking pizzas in a fieldstone wood-fired oven.

The two chefs are a bit of a culinary odd couple: Wiseman is a French-trained cook who lived and worked in Mexico for many years; Knauer is a hands-on-the-land grower and experimenter. And that, they say, is why their collaboration works. They draw from their diverse strengths and challenge each other to think differently.

Their classes prove it, running the gamut from knife skills and foundation courses in stewing and breadmaking to Italian classics and French brunch. Guest chefs offer classes on myriad topics—Turkish or Malaysian cooking, a series on meat (from butchering to cooking game), and another on fine wine.

The Farm Cooking School is in the Delaware Valley, just down the road from Lambertville and across the river from Bucks County, Pennsylvania, which is renowned for its rich agricultural land. In recent years, more young farmers than ever have found a welcome in the area, meeting the needs of cooks like Wiseman and Knauer. In fact, they have a built-in source of fresh produce for their school, because it is set amid the fields of Malaika Spencer’s Roots to River Farm, which grows organic herbs and vegetables.

On the day of our class, plump tomatoes and tomatillos and ripe chiles from Spencer’s farm awaited us. They’d been picked that morning, and we used use them in the raw and cooked salsas that we learned to prepare. In addition to grilled chicken and sweet onion, we made taco fillings of deep-fried shrimp and avocado (a surprising and delicious treatment); and grilled corn with scallions and cilantro. Our tortillas, wrapped in cloth napkins and tucked warmly inside fuchsia and orange baskets, were ready and waiting to be filled.

After every class at The Farm, students share a meal (get the complete menu here) at the long table on the terrace where the air is fragranced by the herbs grown nearby. Wiseman showed us how to mix margaritas using tart tamarind pulp and reposado tequila, and to rim our glasses with a chile-salt mixture. Then, we all raised our glasses and toasted our newfound tortilla prowess.


Leave a Comment


  • User avater
    WesleyParks | 09/26/2019

    Thanks for sharing!

  • Cooking_Madness | 09/26/2019

    Awesome Recipe.

  • User avater
    JohnPrice6 | 06/18/2019


Show More

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Delicious Dish

Find the inspiration you crave for your love of cooking

Fine Cooking Magazine

Subscribe today
and save up to 44%

Already a subscriber? Log in.


View All


Follow Fine Cooking on your favorite social networks

We hope you’ve enjoyed your free articles. To keep reading, subscribe today.

Get the print magazine, 25 years of back issues online, over 7,000 recipes, and more.

Start your FREE trial