What is it?

Pure vanilla extract, made by macerating vanilla beans in an alcohol-water mixture, is an easy way to add vanilla flavor to baked goods, as it mixes easily into batters. (It’s also a less costly alternative to vanilla beans.) Aside from being used in overtly vanilla flavored desserts, vanilla extract enhances other flavors (particularly chocolate, coffee, fruit, and nuts) and is used in all kinds of cookies, cakes, and pastries. Imitation vanilla extract is made only from artificial ingredients. While cheaper than pure vanilla extract, its flavor can be harsh.

Kitchen math:

1 tsp. extract = one 2-inch piece vanilla bean

Don’t have it?

Use vanilla beans or vanilla bean paste.

How to choose:

The flavor of the vanilla extract is affected by where the vanilla beans were grown. In general, Madagascar, which is what you’re most likely to find, is sweet and buttery. Tahitian vanilla is known for its fragrant and floral aromas; and Mexican vanilla tastes nuttier. Many good brands are available in larger volumes at discounted rates. Always buy pure vanilla extract (it will be called that on the label), never imitation. Double-strength versions are stronger than single-strength.

How to prep:

The strength of the extract will dissipate with prolonged heat, so if you’re adding extract to something cooked on the stovetop, such as a custard or a poaching liquid, add it after the custard or liquid is off the stove and starting to cool. If using double strength use half as much as called for unless you want a very pronounced vanilla flavor.

How to store:

Because vanilla extract is sensitive to heat and light, keep the bottle in a cool, dark place; it should last for up to a year. And, if there’s a bean in it, may even get stronger.

Cross Reference

vanilla beans

Click here to purchase

Recipes

• 
  Recipe

  Sweet Cherry Sheet Pan Pie

  Summer means fresh cherries are in season, so a juicy, sweet cherry pie is in order. Here, a lattice top gives this pie a classic look.

• 
  Recipe

  Bananas Foster Cream Pie

  The New Orleans dessert of bananas Foster inspired this riff on a classic banana cream pie. It features a layer of rum-spiked sautéed bananas under the traditional pudding filling, plus a…

• 
  Recipe

  Chocolate Espresso Cream Pie

  A layer of rich chocolate ganache under mocha pudding might seem like overkill, but is heaven sent for chocolate lovers. A little espresso powder gives the whipped-cream topping some edge.

• 
  Recipe

  Double Coconut Cream Pie

  This is truly next-level coconut cream pie. Instead of coconut extract, it gets its flavor from reduced, concentrated coconut milk in the custard. It's paired with a layer of salted caramel…

• 
  Recipe

  Strawberry-Rhubarb Blitz Torte

  Possibly called “blitz” because the stunning cake can be baked, cooled, and assembled quickly compared to traditional layer cakes, this dessert is a showstopper. Tender, golden cake layers are topped…

• 
  Recipe

  Old-School Coconut Cream Pie

  Shreds of coconut give the creamy filling some texture. For a twist, substitute 1-1/3 cups coconut milk and 1 cup whole milk, and omit the coconut extract.

• 
  Recipe

  Old-School Banana Cream Pie

  A layer of firm-ripe bananas hides under rich vanilla pudding and a mound of whipped cream. Classic. We've garnished it with peanuts, but you can omit them if you prefer.

• 
  Recipe

  Old-School Chocolate Cream Pie

  Flaky crust? Check. Chocolate pudding? Check. Heaps of whipped cream? Check. A sprinkling of chocolate curls or shards on top makes a nice contrast to the whipped cream.

• 
  Recipe

  Milky Swirl Brownies

  These rich, almost creamy brownies are an amazing treat for chocolate lovers. The condensed milk lightly caramelizes at the brownie edges during baking. You might not want to share those…

• 
  Recipe

  Chocolate Raspberry Charlotte Royale

  Deep chocolate cake and ganache with a creamy raspberry interior and a stunning presentation make this showstopper the perfect end to any celebratory meal. See the article for step-by-step photos.…