Reviews

• 
  dgper | 09/01/2018

  This is delicious if made according to directions and yes, you will need more than 4.5 pounds tomatoes to get to 10 cups. BIGGEST CAUTION: DO NOT PROCESS THE TOMATOES THROUGH A FOOD MILL like I just did for my second attempt this year. When the recipe says coarsely chopped that's what it means. You have to peel, seed, and chop them by hand. If you pass the tomatoes through a mill you will have thin tomato liquid. Great for sauces, not so great for this jam. I'm still trying after 2 1/2 hours to see if this will cook down to jam. Otherwise I wasted 5 lbs. of garden tomatoes unless I can think of another use for too-sugary tomato sauce. I may try adding more typical sauce ingredients (basil, parm, spices, etc.) and maybe a bit of balsamic and oil. We'll see what happens.

• 
  pokano | 09/03/2017

  I weighed out 4.5 lb of tomatoes from my garden. That equalled about 4 cups of chopped tomatoes, nowhere near the 10 cups the recipe says 4.5 lb will yield. So not knowing which was correct--the recipe's weight or volume--I used about 5.5 lb of tomatoes with the same quantities as the recipe calls for of the other ingredients. I also peeled the tomatoes. It took 4-5 hours to cook down to a jam consistency, yielding a little less than 2 cups of jam. The jam was not too sweet.

• 
  karolynl | 11/21/2014

  This is the best. But like all the others have said it's way too sweet for me. I used 1/2 cup of coconut sugar, and it was perfect, and extra red pepper flakes. I have now made this 3 times, the family can't get enough of it. Great on grilled cheese sandwiches.